October 2020

Fishing Topwater Lures - James Niggemeyer's Rules of Thumb

James Niggemeyer explains the conditions that lead him to choose the KVD Sexy Dawg or the KVD Splash to chase topwater bites.

I love to throw topwaters, just like everyone else. Two of my favorites are the Strike King Sexy Dawg and the KVD Splash. Whenever I’m out there and I feel like there might be a topwater bite, I’m going to have both of these at the ready.

There are some guidelines on which lure, the Sexy Dawg or the Splash, I’ll choose to throw and when I’ll throw them. It mostly depends on the weather.

Sunny Day

If it’s a brighter day where the fish are tighter to cover and not wanting to leave that cover to chase a bait, then I’ll select the KVD Splash. This is a bait that I’ll throw near where a fish will be, and I’ll chug it. Pop-pop-pop, pause, pop-pop-pop, pause.

The concave mouth spits some water, and it enables me to work the bait in shorter, smaller strike zones when the fish do not want to come for a bait. This is my sniper-style bait when I know where a fish will be. That’s when I reach for the Splash, generally.

Cloudy Day

If it’s overcast, or the fish are aggressive and wanting to chase something, then I’ll reach for a Sexy Dawg. I work this bait with the walk-the-dog cadenceright then left in a steady pattern. It can be difficult to find the rod rhythm, but once you get the Sexy Dawg going with the rattle in it, the directional change can yield some explosive strikes. When the fish are willing to leave cover to get the bait, that’s when I go for the Sexy Dawg.

Experiment to figure out what works for you. There are some days when the fish will throw the rules upside down, but these are some general guidelines for when to throw which bait.

Related Articles

March 2022

When to Throw a Swim Jig vs Flippin Jig
Read More

March 2022

Wacky Rig vs. Texas Rig Bait Comparison with the Lew's Hypermag Reel
Read More

January 2022

Squarebill vs. Spinnerbait
Read More

February 2022

Pre-spawn Fishing Baits and Locations
Read More

April 2021

Kevin VanDam Explains How He Fishes a KVD Sexy Frog
Read More

January 2021

History of Strike King's Hybrid Hunter Bait
Read More

March 2022

How to Skip A Baitcaster Like A Pro
Read More

March 2022

Using Topwater Baits During the Spawn
Read More

February 2022

Pre-Spawn Cranking Breakdown
Read More